A 92-Eagle Weekend at Waggoner’s Gap, PA
North
America’s largest predatory bird, the Golden Eagle (above), is little-known to birders
in the East. But, in season, there is one spot where one is almost guaranteed a
glimpse of this marvelous bird—Waggoner’s Gap, Pennsylvania.
The
eastern-nesting Golden Eagles breed in the far north of Ontario, Quebec, and Labrador—vast
unroaded boreal and subarctic lands rarely visited by birders. They move south
in the winter, settling mainly into the central Appalachians, where they are
best seen at hidden sites where highway departments dump the carcasses of roadkilled
White-tailed Deer. Camera-traps set at isolated carcass dumps show Golden Eagles tangling with
Coyotes, Common Ravens, Fishers, and other predators and scavengers.
The
more familiar Bald Eagle much outnumbers the Golden in the East and nests through
most of the Lower 48. Waggoner’s Gap counts in excess of 700 Bald Eagles
annually. That’s a lot of eagles!
The
weather favored by migrating eagles is the passage of a serious cold front that
brings strong northwest winds. The winds help these big birds find updrafts
along Appalachian ridges in New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania.
November
cold fronts also bring small numbers of two much rarer raptors, the American
Goshawk and Rough-legged Hawk, and birders watching for Golden Eagles also hope
for these two rarities. Then there are a half-dozen other raptors, plus migrating
waterfowl and flocks of wandering songbirds that pass through, making a day
atop the mountain entertaining.
From
late October onward, I visited Weather.com regularly, in search of back-to-back
days that predicted good NW winds. These are not as commonplace as they once
used to be, because of the vagaries of climate change. But this year, the 14th
and 15th of November showed promise, so I booked a cheap motel outside
of Carlisle, and drove the 2 hours north from Bethesda on Friday afternoon to
be in position on Saturday morning, the 14th.
I rose before dawn on Saturday and headed to the Carlisle Diner, to power up with coffee and a big plate of old-fashioned breakfast—eggs, potatoes, toast and, of course the local speciality—scapple, well-browned. I arrived at the hawk-watch parking lot by 8AM. After putting on various extra layers, I slowly hiked up to the top of the rocky ridge, where I found Paul Fritz, who was the official hawk-counter for the morning. Over the years, I have spent dozens of days up on the ridge with Paul. He is an expert on North American raptors, and had lived in Alaska for several years, where he also did hawk counts at Gunsight Mountain. I always pepper Paul with questions about hawk migration, and he never fails to give a smart answer to my pesky queries.
Turkey VultureWe
were atop the Kittatiny Ridge, sitting on a rough hill of stacked-up Early
Silurian sandstone slabs, some 440 million years old. The ridge gives great
views to valleys north and south. Looking south and east one can see Dickinson
College and the smokestack of the infamous 3-Mile Island power plant.
With
the northwest winds blowing against the ridge, which is oriented NE to SW, the migrating
raptors tend to show up from the NE, staying mainly on the north side of the
big ridge. At this time of the year, the sun rises in the ESE, so the view to
where the hawks arrive is well illuminated by a sun to the south. But of course
this morning was cloudy with a few early bouts of sleety snow passing overhead.
But
back to my hawk-watch outfit… because of the exposure, elevation, and relentless
wind, it is good to dress in many layers. Best to overdress! This morning I wore
following: Head protection: silk hood, thick polyester pull-over hood, woolen
neck collar, and thick woolen watch cap. Upper body: long underwear upper,
Underarmor heavy mock turtle, down vest, and puffy down coat. Lower body: long
underwear, jeans, and thick ski warmup pants. Feet: woolen sox and low-cut Bean
boots (this is the only place where I have probably underdressed—a heavierweight
boot is recommended.)
We
got our first Bald Eagle at 8:05am and first Golden Eagle at 8:30am. The last
Golden Eagle arrived at 5:06pm. The day produced totals of 15 Goldens and 23
Bald Eagles. That’s a day-total of 38 eagles—not bad! The mountain was visited
by ca. 50 visitors, including about 15 dedicated hawk-watchers.
The
most common raptor of the day was Red-tailed Hawk (32 birds).
Other
raptors included 3 Turkey Vultures, 2 Northern Harriers, 3 Sharp-shinned Hawks,
3 Merlins, and 1 Peregrine Falcon.
Non-raptor
migrant included some large waterbirds: 5 Common Loons, 4 Tundra Swans, and 8
Ring-billed Gulls.
Passerines
(songbirds) included: 4 Snow Buntings, large flocks of Cedar Waxwings, and American
Goldfinches. The sole mammal sighting was of a confiding Red-backed Vole that
came up out of the rocks to take bits of bird seed being put out for the resident
songbirds (Dark-eyed Juncos mainly). Other passers-by include Pileated, Hairy,
and Red-bellied Woodpeckers, White-breasted Nuthatches, and chickadees
(presumably hybrid Black-capped x Carolina).
The
disappointment of the day would be the lack of “close approach” passages by the
eagles. Here is my best Golden Eagle photo for the day (contrast this with the
stunners from other years). In fact, On this day I did not shoot a single raptor
close up, which is unusual, and presumably a product of the wind speed and
direction…
On Sunday, Day 2, I arrived around 8am to see the official counter, Tom Filip, setting up. The two of us had the mountain to ourselves for about an hour. Additional watchers started showing up shortly before 9am. The day would see at least 50 people come up on the rocks, again including about 15 dedicated watchers. Over the weekend, visitors drove in from State College, New York City, and Philadelphia (all 2-3 hours distant). Most made the drive in hopes of seeing some Goldens (and perhaps a Gos or a Rough-leg).
The wind blew and big banks of dark clouds passed overhead.
near-collision between a Red-tailed Hawk and Bald EagleVistas
down into the valleys were picturesque. It was a bit late for the leaves, the
remnants of which were mainly shades of brown.
There’s
lots of bantering that goes on between the veteran watchers, which makes
sitting with the group fun. There is also lots of raptor talk, with the
visitors (like me) asking questions of the Senior Watchers, who are perhaps the
most knowledgeable raptor watchers in North America.
Sunday
featured 40 Golden Eagles and a paltry 14 Bald Eagles. It’s not often that
Goldens outnumber Balds, a species that seems to be doing very well in the US
these days (let’s not speak of the ongoing catastrophe of the Osprey population
in the Chesapeake Bay ecosystem thanks to the overharvest of Atlantic Menhaden).
Other
raptors included 17 Turkey Vultures, 1 harrier, 7 Sharpies, 2 Cooper’s Hawks, 2
Red-shouldered Hawks, 56 Red-tails, and no falcons. A single Merlin came in
early and perched in a tree just east of the watch, but was never seen to cross
the line west of the watch, which is required to consider the bird a migrant. We
also watched several non-counter Black Vultures, which, officially, are
non-migratory (though it looked like they were migrating to me!).
There
were two big waterbird migrant surprises: a stately pair of Sandhill Cranes lumbered
over.
And
131 Common Loons and 1 Red-throated Loon zipped over in groups, one which
totalled 53 birds.
Songbirds
included Pine Siskins, goldfinches, Eastern Bluebirds, Purple Finches, Cedar
Waxwings, plus a singleton Horned Lark and singleton Snow Bunting.
Regarding
the massive Golden Eagle flight, 12 birds passed by 11AM, 15 passed between 11
and 2PM, and 13 passed between 2PM and 4:44PM the time of the last bird. The
all-time day-count at Waggoner’s for Golden Eagles is 50, so this Sunday was
definitely a red-letter day. And as with Saturday, photographic conditions were
poor and the best I could manage is featured below.
I provide the disappointing images to make it clear to hawk-lovers who read this that a visit to Waggoner’s Gap, even when lots of eagles are passing by, does not guarantee you will get closeup looks at birds through your binoculars. Many identified migrants are seen at great distance, being identified by experts deploying their powerful spotting scopes.
a "V" of Tundra SwansTo
poor mortals with 8 power binoculars, these distant birds are little more than
dark specks moving along the distant northern Tuscarora ridgeline. So it is
possible to spent 7 hours on the ridgetop and get no more than 1-2 good looks
at passing raptors.
But…
as evidenced by the best images presented here (from other autumns) it is
possible to have superb looks at gorgeous birds. That’s one of the things that
makes it all worthwhile. The other thing is the camaradery and fun spending
time with a bunch of nature-lovers who are smart, knowledgeable, and welcoming.
Don’t worry, they will ID all the birds that you see, even at great distance!
Virtually
all of the images I display here were shot in different years, and some were
shot at Cape May, NJ. I present them here to entertain the reader, and give
them hope for a great day at Waggoner’s in the future!

